Wednesday, January 21, 2015

Chapter 2. Pioneers

Monument to Joseph Smith and his brother, Hyrum, in Nauvoo, Illinois 


Chapter 2: Pioneers

“A new American Religion”

In upstate New York in the spring of 1820, 14 year old Joseph Smith returned from praying in the woods near his home in Palmyra relating that he had seen a heavenly vision and that he was to be the instrument through which God would restore his Gospel again to the earth. By 1830, a new book of scripture, the “Book of Mormon” had been published, the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints had been officially organized and missionaries were being sent out to teach this new “Gospel”.

While many embraced this new church, most found its teachings and young “prophet” peculiar at best, a threatening menace at worst.  Persecution of the new movement led to resettlement in Kirtland, Ohio, near present day Cleveland, and then on to the Midwest.  After several turbulent years along the Missouri frontier, in 1839, Joseph Smith and his people settled on the east side of the Mississippi River in southern Illinois and established the city of Nauvoo.  Here, they enjoyed a time of peace and prosperity in which many missionaries were sent throughout the eastern United States and Europe. Thousands joined the movement and answered the call to join the “Saints” - to establish a modern day Zion in America. Sometime before 1848, Thomas Armstrong Chappell and his wife Sarah Marie Gavitt heard and accepted this message. 

While the exact date and location of this conversion is unknown, it is supposed they joined the Church in Connecticut.  The Mormon Elders would enter into a community and hold meetings in which they would preach their message and invite participants to study and learn more.  Thomas, upon hearing the message, felt of its truth, and embraced this new faith and headed the call to gather with the main body of Saints, who by 1846, had already began their western migration. ‘

While little is known of the conversion of Thomas Chappell and Sarah Marie Gavitt to Mormonism, their story is likely similar in many ways, to that of the Sperry and Sidwell families

Aurilla Sperry’s grandfather, Joy Sperry, and her mother, Mary Lamont, first heard the Mormon Elders while living the La Harpe, Illinois.  From the Journal of Aurilla’s uncle, Harrison Sperry, we have the following:

“….The Mormon Elders came into our community.  My father went to their meetings to hear them. He embrace their faith and joined them.  I used to go with my father to many of their meetings. Very frequently they would speak in tongues.  I  became very interested in Mormonism and told my father that I wished to be baptized. It was not long after this when the Mormon Elders announced that there was going to be a baptismal day in a small stream not far away.  I along with a great many others, including my sister, Sarah, was baptized by one Samuel Gurley.  We were confirmed by Samuel and others at the water’s edge. This was in the fall of 1841.  The next March I would have been ten years old.”

“Shortly after my baptism mobs gathered and commenced to threaten the people and make trouble throughout the whole of Hancock, County, Illinois.  My father was amount those warned to leave the country.  I remember very well an incident down on the creek bottoms while we were hunting cows that had strayed out that evening.  I looked across the creek.  A horseman was coming toward us.  He proved to be one of our townsmen by the name of Post.  He informed us he had been to a meeting that evening.  He hade been picked by these people to cover a certain district. He said that it was his responsibility to warn the Mormon in the district to leave the county.  I remember how my father reacte34d.  He straightened up and commenced to talk in serious tones to Mr. Post.   He said, “I and my family have been some of the first settlers in La Harpe.  We have tried at all times to be good citizens.  I have four boys and myself.  We all have guns and ammunition. If you come after us, I can guarantee, we will make it mighty warm for you.”  They never came after us.” 

“The mobs became increasingly more threatening.  They marched up and down the county, mostly at night, trying to burn down Mormon property, stacks and houses., Most of the Mormons were on the lookout fo them.  They had to remain continually on guard night and day to keep the mobs form doing violence and burning houses.  These insensible mobs were determined to drive the Mormons out of the country.  Finally they trumped up a charge against the Mormon Prophet, Joseph Smith. He and his brother, Hyrum Smith, were arrested.  They surrendered to the authorities at Carthage, who placed them in prison there.  They had been promised a fare trial, but on the 27th of June, 1844, the Carthage Grays, a band of blackened faced ruffians, advanced on the jail with guns and brutally murdered the Prophet and his brother, Hyrum. Later these same mobs not being completely satisfied with the killing of the Prophet and his brother, tried a raid upon Nauvoo with about 3000 men.  A real battle ensued resulting in the death of some Mormons and also some of the mob.  Finally, in order to avoid further bloodshed, a treaty was made.  The Mormon community was forced to agree to leave the country.”

“After the death of the Prophet, Brigham Young, being the President of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles of the Church was chosen to lead the people.  Brigham Young’s words were:  “To your tents, Oh Israel”.  Preparations for leaving were going on during the winter of 1845 and all through 1846.  Wagons were made; teams were bartered and traded for; homes were sold; and improvements were sold for as much as they could get for them. However a great many had to leave their homes and furniture unsold.  Very early in the spring of 1846, the Great Exodus Began.”

“During the spring of 1846, as the weather got warmer, the Great Exodus feeling was so noticeable. In the spirit of the times, my father sold our home, in reality he rather gave it away.  The house in the values of the times was worth two or tree thousand dollars, but father got only a span of horses and a harness for it.  Undiscouraged as a family we loaded up our effects; and in the spring of 1846 we started for the West.  Our family party consisted of my father, Joy Sperry, my mother Mary Lamont Sperry, two sisters, Betsey and Sarah; four brothers, William, Aaron, Charles, and Harrison.  We also had a little niece called Josephine.  We left La Harpe and its memories and went down to the Mississippi River.  Here we place my sister Sarah on a northbound Mississippi steamboat. She traveled up the river to a town call Oquaua, Iowa.  There her lover, Mr. Asa Abbott, met her and they were married.  She never saw her father or her mother again.”

“The remainder of our family crossed the Mississippi River and began our march westward, not even knowing where we were going. It was an act of faith.” (1)

While Aurilla Sperry’s father’s family joined the Church in western Illinois and suffered with the Saints there, her mother’s family learned of Mormonism in Pennsylvania.  Her mother was Margaret Ann Sidwell, daughter of Job Sidwell and Susan Robbinson.  From their family history we have the following:

“Job Sidwell was born on the sixth of June, 1801, in Little Briton, West Chester County, Pennsylvania.  He was the son of Job Vincent Sidwell and Rebeecca Thetzer Sidwell. He was an American descent.  There were ten children, five boys and five girls in the family.  They were farmer, stock and sheep raisers.  Job , the second, was a hatter by trade.  They were Quakers by faith, followers of the great William Penn.”

“Job married Susan Robbinson who was born October 17, 1808 in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania.  She was of American and Irish descent.  There was a large family on her side.  The Sidwells were not wealthy but were quite well to do.  They had all the comforts of life and owned their colored servants.  In 1845 they heard the Gospel preached by LDS missionaries and were converted to the truthfulness of the same and out of large families on both sides were the only ones who became members of the Church.”

“As soon as they became members of the church, the spirit of gathering took possession of them as a desire to follow the Mormons.  They could not settle to work or feel contented at anything.  Their parents, brothers, sisters, friends were very much opposed to them ever thinking of selling out and did everything in their power to persuade them to give up Mormonism but no persuasion or anything they could say or do had the least effect.  They sold everything they could and whey they could not sell, they left behind.” 

“In the year 1846 they left home, parents, brothers, and sisters, kindred and ties never to see again in this life for their religion and with four living children, Margaret Ann, age 18 years, George 16, John 7, Rebecca Catherine 4, they started out.  They hired teams to take them to Pittsburg and from there the took the canal boat to Columbus, from there to Cincinnati when by steam boat from there to St. Louis and to Winter Quarters. They then went back to St Joe and stayed all winter.”

“They bought five yoke of oxen and three wagons and supplies.  They had plenty when they started out.  They met Jedidiah M. Grant’s company in Winter Quarters in the spring of 1847 and started for the Rocky Mountains.  They were in the Joseph Nobles captain of 50 and Hazen Kimball captain of  10.  Grandpa  drove on yoke , his son George, tow yoke, Margaret Ann and John, one yoke. They had three cows, two pigs, and some chickens. They brought seeds and a few potatoes.  They met Wilford Woodruff and Orson Hyde who had just come from Nauvoo and grandpa gave several, hundred dollars to them for the Camp of Israel. He gave also one hundred  each to Woodruff and Hyde to help them on their way.” (2)


The death of Joseph Smith in June of 1844, in Carthage, Illinois, was a terrible shock, not only to the thousands of Mormons now living in and around Nauvoo, but to the many living throughout the eastern United States and Europe.  While the Quorum of Twelve Apostles, led by Brigham Young, felt certain Joseph had given them the right and authority to lead the Church, Joseph never made this publicly clear to the general membership prior to his death.  While the majority of the Saints did follow Brigham Young and the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles, the debate about who was the rightful heir to lead the Latter-Day Saints was not at all clear in the minds of many.  As we shall see, this debate touched the lives of the Chappell and Sperry families in very personal ways. (Please see appendix A: The Oatman Massacre)

Prior to his death, Joseph Smith prophesied that the Saints would eventually move to the Rocky Mountains and become a mighty people there. (3). Once the persecutors of the Mormons realized the movement was not going to disband with the death of their prophet, pressure again increased to drive the people out of Nauvoo.  In search of piece and religious freedom, the Latter-day Saints, under the direction of Brigham Young, prepared to move west beyond the borders of the United States, into Mexican territory in the Great Basin of the Rocky Mountains.  The exodus began in February of 1846 and was in full swing by spring of that year.  The original plan was to move a large number of the people to the Rocky Mountains that first year. However, Iowa was much more difficult to cross than anticipated.

The wet spring turned the Iowa prairie into a large mud bog.  The warm weather so anxiously anticipated, turned the ice and snow into mud and mire.  Travel was slowed to only 1-2 miles a day.  The up and down terrain with slushy bogs in the bottom and slipping slopes on each side required great effort on the part of man and beast just to make head way at all.

Regarding the difficulties of the trek across Iowa, we have from the history of Harrison Sperry:

“The roads were extremely muddy, and we had storms almost every day.  We continued west through Iowa until we were upon the Grand River. There the Saints had fashioned a resting place.  It was named, Mount Pisgah.  My father  pushed on to the bottoms of the Grand River, felled trees, cleared away the brush, plowed, and put in a little garden.  We also built a shanty-like house for the family.  Everything was of a temporary nature, but in this condition we remained most f the summer.”

“It was while we were still at Mount Pisgah that my brothers, William, Aaron, and Charles took our horse team back to Bonepart, Iowa, on the Des Moines River to work n the harvest and get more provisions to take with us on the journey west.  While they were away our mother took sick. We were living in a little shanty built from the trees we had felled. We had covered it with bark.  We built it at the same time we prepared the garden.  My father called to me one day.  “Harrison,” he said, “I wish you would go over to Brother Mansfield’s.  Tell him to come over because I believe mother is dying.”  Brother Mansfield lived up the river about twenty rods or more. It was a trail through the brush and very dark. When I got there I asked him to come.  He replied feebly, “I cannot because we are all sick, too”.  When I got back, mother was just breathing her last breath. Shortly after mother was buried at Mount Pisgah, Aaron and Charles returned.  William had gone back to La Harpe to attend to some of our business. He joined us again at Hyland Grove.  About this time some of our La Harpe friends came along. They had heard that we were sick and in trouble.  As good friends they came to our camp and offered to assist us. We gladly accepted their offer, gathered up our teams, put our goods in the wagons, and went on west with them, finally stopping at a place near Council Bluffs, Iowa, called Hyland Grove.  It was their we made our winter quarters.“(4)


Having only minimal knowledge of their eventual destination and the difficulty they would encounter in getting there, prudence suggested they winter over and resume their journey in the spring. On the western shore of the Missouri River, just north of present day Omaha, Nebraska, the Saints set up their “Winter Quarters”.  They built rough log cabins, planted crops and prepared for winter.  In future annals of Mormon History, Winter Quarters was to become synonymous with great suffering.  The severe winter of 1846-47 combined with the crude accommodations, terrible sanitary conditions and disease, resulted in the death of hundreds of people that first winter. (5)

While the main body of Saints suffered in Winter Quarters, the Sperry family spent the winter in the small encampment at Hyland Grove. It was one of many such encampments on the Iowa side of the river. The Sperry’s suffered greatly that winter as we again read in Harrison Sperry’s journal:

“A group of Saints had reached Hyland Grove before us.  In anticipation of winter they had built some rude log houses.  Among these fine people was a good friend by the name of Behormon.  He had built a double log house. Even though he had  a large family, he proffered to let us come in and live with him until we could build.  We will never forget his unselfish kindness.   It was while we were living in Behormon’s house during the early winter of 1846, the whole family came down sick with the “durned” Ague (A fever similar to malaria marked by chills, fever and sweating at regular intervals). In addition to this, my brother Aaron developed blackleg (Scurvy). It was caused by not having enough green vegetables to eat.  Great sores appeared on is legs and the tops of his feet.  Maggots were often in his sores.  Aaron died in the month of December 1846. He was buried in the grove nearby.”

“Brother Behormon and his boys were graciously building a house for us because we were all so sick.  It was near and we moved into it right after my brother died.  My father wasn’t able to rally like the rest of us and continued very sick.  We had no medicines.  We had nothing with which to help him.  On New Year’s Day in 1847, my father died.  He was 62 years old.  We buried him by the side of my brother Aaron.  There is no gravestone at Hyland Grove to show where they lay.  Hyland Grove is about seven miles east of Winter Quarters (Florence, Nebraska), or just across the Missouri River from the present Omaha, Nebraska.”

“Before our father died, he called his whole family around his bedside.  He requested us to follow the heads of the Church, who were moving west.  This we unanimously agreed to do.  Accordingly, during the spring of 1847, after the grass had grown sufficiently for travel, we hitched up our teams, loaded in our good and our outfit.  We were moving out west.”(6)


As spring approached in 1847, the Saints were restless. Even though they were moving off into a great unknown, most of the inhabitants were more than anxious to be away from this terrible place and back on the trail that spring and summer.  The lead group of immigrants directed by Brigham Young arrived in the valley of the Great Salt Lake July 24th, 1847.  History states that upon entering the valley from an eastern canyon, Brigham Young, ill from Mountain Fever, raised up from his sick bed in the back of a wagon, gazed over the valley before him and after a few moments stated, “This is the right place, drive on”. (7) Following behind President Young, several other companies followed, including the Jedadiah M. Grant Company of which the Sperry and Sidwell families were a part.  When the last wagon train arrived in October of 1847, nearly 1900 Mormons had arrived in their new Zion in the west. (8)

Harrison Sperry, brother to William Lamont Sperry, father of Aurilla Sperry, recorded many of the adventures and challenges of a cross continental wagon train excursion.  He was fifteen years old at the time.  The following are some excerpts from his personal journal:

“One day while our company was traveling west along the north shore of the Platt River, a large band of Indians approached our camp.  They wanted to buy whiskey, sugar, and a white squaw. Unfortunately, we were just our of white squaws and whiskey for sale.  However, we did trade them some sugar and floor.  Another morning as we were about to continue the trek, we looked off to the bluffs.  Thousands of buffalo were coming straight for our camp.  They were on the way to the Platte River for water.  It was immediately apparent that we had to send out men with guns.  They had to fire their rifles in order to turn the herd from overrunning our camp.  This also prevented them from stampeding our ox teams, all hitched to our wagons. We were detained almost a half day while this big herd passed.  After the buffalo went down to the river and drank, some returned in the direction from whence they came. Others swam over the river and disappeared.  After the danger had passed, we drove on.  Buffalo were so numerous all along the plains, we could go out and kill one almost any time we wished.”

“Another time when the train was moving west in full tranquility, suddenly the whole picture changed.  Every one of us found ourselves in a wild stampede.  The cause of it was the hind team.  They got lazy and loitered behind. In order to close the distance, the teamster had overdone the use of his whip.   They caught up with the team ahead of them and ran by them. That action scared the team ahead.  Similarly it went through the whole camp until the entire train was running recklessly ahead.  A considerable number of women and children were walking.  When they saw the teams and wagons all running away, they got scared.  They ran after us howling and in tears.  Everything was in an uproar.  With a great effort and considerable confusion, we finally got the teams stopped.  Order was restored. Luckily no one was hurt.  With some greater experience and caution we continued our journey west. “

“Another time when Indian danger was high, we camped and corralled our animals.  It was decided to take the cattle out to feed.  About dark they were brought in again.  After super and prayers were over, everything became quiet.  We had retired to rest.  One of the steers came up to one of the wagons and probably jiggled it a little.  This angered on of the sleepers in the wagon.  He got up and in righteous anger threw a buffalo robe on the critter’s head.  That action frightened the animal.  He started to run.  Others join in. Soon the whole herd was running around the corral in fright.  Finally the herd broke out of the corral, smashing the wagon placed across the opening.  The whole herd went out, taking the back track and running for several miles before hey could be stopped. You can bet the whole camp was aroused. Men on horseback started after the animals, and it was almost daylight when they brought them back.  Every tragedy has its humorous moments- for after the herd had passed over the wagon at the opening of the corral, mashing it down, a young lady crawled out fro under the debris and innocently asked what was the uproar.  It was miraculous that this young lady was not trampled to death. …Next morning teams were hitched up as usual. We continued our journey. “

“ Thus traveling west, day after day, we eventually came in sight of the mountains.  They loomed up a hundred miles ahead of us. The tops of the mountains were so high that they were capped with snow.  It seemed an intolerably long time before we reached those big Rocky Mountains.  Storms began with our reaching the mountains.  It was very cold and disagreeable at times - snow falling in places several inches in depth”

“We traveled through the mountains for a long time and finally came upon Big Mountain.  Here we got a sight of our promised valley and the Great Salt lake.  It looked scenic to see such a large open basin.  However, at the speed we were moving, it took another day or two of mountain travel down through the canyon before we  reached the valley. Our company, under the leadership of Jedediah M. Grand, emerged into the Salt Lake Valley on or about the 17th of October, 1847.  It was late in the year, and the next most important thing to do was to prepare for winter.“ (9)

Meanwhile, back along the Missouri River, Winter Quarters continued to be the final staging area for immigrating Mormons through the fall of 1848.  It being on Indian territory, the main encampment was eventually moved back across the river from Nebraska into Iowa .  We do not know if the Chappell family from Connecticut, made up of Thomas Armstrong Chappell, his wife Sarah Marie Gavitt, his mother in law, Mary Nye Gavitt, and their children, George Armstrong, Edwin and Sally spent the winter of 1847-48 in Winter Quarters. If they did, they likely endured similar suffering to those who had spent the winter the previous year. Many other smaller Mormon camps were set up both on the Iowa and Nebraska sides of the river and they may have spent the winter there. It is possible they wintered  further east, but in any case, come June 1848, they were at Winter Quarters and a part of the Heber C Kimball company soon to be joining others in the westward trek of over a thousand miles to the Great Salt Lake Valley.

Heber C Kimball was a close associate of Joseph Smith, a brother in law to Brigham Young, one of the Twelve Apostles of the Church and a revered leader of the day.  He had joined the Mormons in 1832 in upstate New York and had been a participant in the early rise of the Church and the persecutions of Ohio, Missouri and Illinois.  He was familiar with the trail from Winter Quarters to the Great Salt Lake Valley in that he had made the trip the previous year with Brigham Young. After a short stay in the Salt Lake Valley, he had turned around and headed back east to rejoin his family and the Saints still residing in the east.

The Heber C Kimball Company of 1848 consisted of 662 individuals when it left Winger Quarters on June 7, 1848 and arrived in Great Salt Lake City September 24. (10) Even though the trip itself went without undo hazards, the beginning was difficult in that on June 6,1848, the company was involved in a gun battle with local Indians who had attempted to steal cattle. Heber C Kimball in his journal records:

Tuesday 6th about 8 o clock an alarm was brought to camp, by one of the herdsboys, that Indians were driving off some of the cattle, from the herd about two miles below. A number of the brethren immediately started in pursuit, some on foot and some on horses. Howard Egan and Wm. H[enry]. Kimball went in company, and were afterwards joined by [Thomas Edwin] Ricks & [Noah Willis] Bartholomew all having horses. They proceeded at a rapid pace about six miles down the river and as they went heard a number of shots fired which created much anxiety for the safety of those on foot. When about six miles from camp, they came suddenly upon a party of about ten armed Indians who appeared very hostile, but the brethren did not anticipate any danger, their object being to hunt for the cattle and if they found any to drive them back. However, immediately on the arrival of the brethren amongst the Indians the latter fired several shots, one of which took affect on Ricks, who fell from his horse to the ground apparently dead. At the same instant Howard Egan observed an Indian standing about 20 or 25 feet from them, and taking a dead aim with his rifle at Wm. Kimball, quick as thought he levelled his pistol and fired at the Indian to save W's life. The rifle fell from the Indians hands, but in falling it exploded the ball passing through the fleshy part of Wms. horses hip. The Indian then ran off, but during this scene another Indian had fired upon Egan, the ball passing through his right arm above the wrist, mangling it severely, which caused his pistol (a six shooter) to drop to the ground. Another ball passed through his horses neck which caused him to wheel round making it difficult for Egan to keep the saddle. The brethren then saw it was best to retreat on account of lack of numbers and arms, and seeing that the Indians were determined to fight. All this scenery was but the work of a moment, during which time shots were heard in several other directions. The brethren then drew off towards camp, some distance, leaving Ricks on the ground, and on looking back, they observed one of the Indians proceed towards where Ricks lay & they feared it was to scalp him. However he only picked up the pistol and then followed the others down the river. Es [E]gan soon grew faint with loss of blood and had to be held on his horse by Wm. Kimball, who also bound up his arm with his handkerchief to staunch the blood. They then proceeded onwards towards the camp untill they arrived at the place where they crossed the river (being now on the East side) and here they found several other brethren and informed them of Ricks's situation, requesting them to fetch him to camp, which they agreed to do, and started accordingly by Es Egan and Wm. Kimball then proceeded slowly towards camp taking a circuit towards the bluffs, to avoid the timber, untill they saw some wagons going towards the camp, which proved to be a company with Martin H[orton]. Peck. On arriving at the wagons Es Egan was put in one of them being very faint with loss of blood, and they soon after arrived at the Ford of the Elk Horn. Here Dr. [John Milton] Bernhisel was sent for, and he dressed the wound, and ascertained that no bones were broke. The facts above being made known in camp brother Joel Ricks and T[homas]. [Levi] Whittle with one or two others, took a light wagon, and started to fetch up brother Ricks’ son, proceeding down the East side the river. On arriving near the place where they expected to find the wounded, they were surprised and taken prisoners by a party of 20 or 30 Indians, who took them some distance down the river. The brethren had a trunk or trunks in the wagon which the Indians ransacked, taking a number of articles, and a good coat, worth fifteen dollars. After doing this, and making many signs and gestures of a hostile character, they let the brethren go without farther harm, and they immediately returned towards camp, learning by the way, that the wounded man, had already been taken to camp by the route on the other side the river. Those brethren who started at the request of Es Egan and Wm. Kimball, together with others who joined them went back to this place, where the affray took place, and found brother Ricks still laying in the same place and alive. They took him up and proceeded with him towards camp, and were met by a carriage, in which he was placed and about two o clock arrived with him at his fathers wagon. Dr Bernhisel examined him and found that he was wounded by 3 large buckshot having penetrated the small part of his back. The Dr dressed his wound but it was generally believed that he could not long survive. However Prest. Kimball and one or two others laid their hands on him and prayed for his recovery. The Lord heard their prayers and he revived immediately. There were still one or two brethren missing who went out on foot, and much anxiety was felt on their account, but towards evening they arrived safe. The Indians succeeded in killing and carrying off an ox belonging to Br John Pack, but on starting away from the Elk Horn, a stray ox came to his wagon for which no owner could be found, so that the loss was in a measure made up. About 3 o clock the camp commenced moving off from the River, as it was considered wisdom to leave the timber as soon as possible, and all the wagons being over which had then arrived, so that we should not be in so much danger from the attacks of Indians, who, it is pretty certainly ascertained are of the Omaha and Ottoc [Otoe] tribes, and from every circumstance are doubtless in the neighborhood for the purpose of plundering us of cattle &c. Brother C[ornelius]. P[eter]. Lott, Joseph Fielding, sister Mary Smith and families had been expected at the "Horn" soon after dinner and as it was known that they were not far distant some anxiety was felt for their safety, after the camp had moved about 2 miles, and the encampment had been formed, Prest. Kimball sent back 10 footmen, well armed to meet brother Lott and company, and about 5 o clock they arrived all safe with the exception of having broke an axle tree and being very short of team. The wagons were soon ferried across, the chains attached to the raft taken up, the raft made fast, and the last wagons composing this company on their way to camp, and before dark we had the satisfaction of seeing 210 wagons formed in one Carrol [corral] preparatory to our proceeding on our long journey West. Those who were wounded felt as well as could be expected after the short journey. (11)

Even though Thomas Chappell’s name is not mentioned in this account, he along with his family, was certainly aware and an active participant in the dramatic events of this day.

Mormon wagon trains were very organized.  The travelers were organized into companies of 10, 50 and 100 with an assigned leader over each group. From the records of the Heber C Kimball Company, we know that Thomas Chappell was a leader of 10.  His responsibilities would have been oversee and assist the 10 families in his group. 

Harrison Sperry describes the organization of a Mormon immigrant train as follows:

“The company was organized with a captain over 10 wagons, a higher captain over 50 wagans, and a head captain over 100 wagons.  As soon as there were sufficient wagons to make a company of a hundred wagons, they were organized and permitted to move out.  On account of the Indian danger, it was thought to be unsafe to travel with less than that number.” (12)

Regarding the day to day activities of the wagon train, Harrison Sperry describes:

“Our rate of travel varied from about ten to twenty miles a day.  On Sundays, the Sabbath was observed.  We would lay bye and hold meetings.  Sometimes a half day on Saturdays was set aside, to let the women get their washing done.  At times our travel was governed by the amount of feed available for the animals and the distance to water holes.  As a general rule, the food available to the animals was very good. We were short of wood at times and hd to resort to buffalo chips (droppings or the manure of the buffalo) for our fires.  Buffalo chips made good fires when they were dry. “

“Once camp was organized at night, you would see everyone our gathering chips and bringing water in. With the camp fires started, you knew that super was being cooked.  After super the herds were looked after.   Each night four or five men were detailed to the herd, to take them out to feed, to guard them, to make sure that the Indians didn’t sneak them away.  This guard group would stay with them all night, then bring them in early in the morning.  About nine o’clock at night, camp fires were put out. All the camp went to bed.  Sometimes when Indian danger was thought to be great, the herd was brought into the corral, formed of our wagons driven in an oval shape fity wagons on each side, wheels chained together, and a wagon drawn across each entrance. Guards were placed all around the camp.”  (13)

Other notable members of the Heber C. Kimball Company of 1848 include Mary Fielding Smith, widow of Hyrum Smith (brother of Joseph Smith who was also killed in Carthage, Illinois in June, 1844) and her 9 year of son Joseph Fielding Smith, future president of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints. (14)

The three and a half month journey ended on September 24th 1848 when the Chappell family arrived in the Salt Lake Valley.


References:

1.      Harrison Sperry, “Sperry Family Crossing the Plains”, Original Journal of Harrison Sperry, as found in:  “George Armstrong and Aurilla Sperry Chappell”, Compilation of family history and genealogy by the descendants of George Armstrong Chappell and Aurilla Sperry.
2.      “Sidwell Family History”, Compiled by Ettie Jane Sidwell, as recorded in “George Armstrong and Aurilla Sperry Chappell”, Compilation of family history and genealogy by the descendants of George Armstrong Chappell and Aurilla Sperry.
3.      In August of 1842 Joseph Smith prophesied “that the Saints would continue to suffer much affliction and would be driven to the Rocky Mountains, many would apostatize, others would be put to death by our persecutors or lose their lives in consequence of exposure or disease, and some [would] live to … build cities and see the Saints become a mighty people in the midst of the Rocky Mountains” (Documentary History of the Church, 5:85, August, 1842)
4.      Harrison Sperry, “Sperry Family Crossing the Plains.
5.      “Church records for the first summer do not contain information on disease victims; however, later records indicate that, from mid-September 1846 to May 1848, disease caused the deaths of 359 residents”. Wikipedia.com
6.      Harrison Sperry, “Sperry Family Crossing the Plains.
7.      “When he first gazed upon the valley, Brigham Young recorded, the “Spirit of Light rested on me and hovered over the valley, and I felt that there the Saints would find protection and safety.” Years later, Wilford Woodruff elaborated: “He had seen the valley before in vision, and upon this occasion he saw the future glory of Zion and of Israel, as they would be, planted in the valleys of these mountains.” When the vision had passed, President Young said, “It is enough. This is the right place. Drive on.” (Ronald K. Esplin, "A “Place Prepared” in the Rockies", Ensign, July 1988, 7, as quoted from: Manuscript History of Brigham Young, 23 July 1847, Church Archives; and Wilford Woodruff Address, 24 July 1880, The Utah Pioneers, p. 23, quoted in B. H. Roberts, A Comprehensive History of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Century I, 6 vols., (Salt Lake City: Deseret News Press, 1930), 3:224)
8.      “Some confusion exists about the total number entering the valley in 1847. Church historian B.H. Roberts, basing his calculations on Thomas Bullock's reports, asserted a total of 2,095, but he did not take into account the battalion members from California. Leonard J. Arrington estimated that 1,681 pioneers spent the first winter in the valley, and a church letter of 6 March 1848 reported that the total population stood at "1,671 persons living in 423 houses." There were also some births and deaths, and a few battalion men decided to go back east to their families. In addition, some 250 people who came into the Salt Lake Valley in 1847 returned soon afterwards to Winter Quarters or to California. Thus about 1,930 people could claim the title "Pioneers of '47." (Eugene E. Campbell, “Establishing Zion:  The Mormon Church in the American West, Chapter 1, 1847-69”, 1988, Signature Books, Salt Lake City, Utah.)
9.      Harrison Sperry, “Sperry Family Crossing the Plains”.
10.   Mormon Pioneer Overland Trail, 1847-1868, www. lds.org/church history/ library/pioneer company
11.   Heber C Kimball, Journal, Trail Excerpts, lds.org/church history/library/pioneercompanysources
12.   Harrison Sperry, “Sperry Family Crossing the Plains
13.   Harrison Sperry, “Sperry Family Crossing the Plains
14.   Mormon Pioneer Overland Trail, 1847-1868, www. lds.org

Appendix A: The Oatman  Massacre

In early August 1844, just a few weeks after Joseph’s death, the Saints gathered in Nauvoo to address who should lead the church.  The main contenders for the role were Sidney Rigdon, former council to Joseph Smith in the First Presidency of the Church, and Brigham Young, leading apostle in the Council of the Twelve Apostles.  Sidney addressed the congregation first, followed by Brigham Young.  The majority of the Saints felt the authority to lead was with Brigham Young and the Quorum of the Twelve. Many in attendance saw the image of Joseph come over Brigham Young, and as he spoke and heard the voice of their fallen prophet. Brigham Young was to lead the Church.

While the majority of the Saints did follow Brigham Young and the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles, the debate about who was the rightful heir to lead the Latter-Day Saints was not at all clear in the minds of many. 

Joy Sperry’s eldest daughter,  Mary Ann, married Roys Oatman, also from La Harpe, in 1832.  This couple later converted to Mormonism in about 1839 along with the rest of the Sperry family .  While the Sperry family followed Brigham Young, Roys Oatman felt Sidney Rigdon was the rightful leader of the Church.  Roys and Mary Ann followed Rigdon and his supporters to Pennsylvania but soon became disillusioned and returned to western Illinois.  Even though they were again residing near his wife’s family, Roys remained convinced Brigham Young was not the one to lead the Church.  In the spring of 1846, as the Sperry family was making final preparation to move west, Roys and Mary Ann Oatman went to see them off. 

“Joy Sperry and his wife Mary Ann made preparations to leave Hancock County with Brigham Young in the spring of 1846.  Roys and Mary Ann Oatman came down from Whiteside County to see them off.  They wanted, no doubt, to wish Mary Ann’s parents well on their journey westward; they were going to a “New Jerusalem” somewhere in the West, but exactly where not even Brigham Young knew for sure.  But the visit quickly took on a disagreeable tone. Sperry, an ardent Young supporter, may well have tried to persuade the Oatmans to join them on the trek. But Roys wanted none of Young’s leadership.  The two Mormons argued their respective positions for about a week, until the day the Oatmans were to start back to Whiteside County.

Joy’s son Charles later remembered that the two men “got to arguing at the breakfast table and they both got quite warm and in earnest in their argument.”  Finally Roys said to his father-in-law, 
“I see, Father Sperry, it is no use to talk with you. I prophesy in the name of the Lord that if you go west with your family, your children will go hungry and some will starve to death and your throats will be cut from ear to ear by the Indians.” A more reasonable man would have regretted the words as soon as they parted his lips, but Roys Oatman apparently never did so.  Joy Sperry was older, perhaps wiser,  but no less firm in his convictions.  His only reply to Roys was “Be careful how you prophesy in the name of the Lord”. (As quoted in book by Brian McGinty “The Oatman Massacre: A Tale of Desert Captivity and Survival”, 2006)


This prophecy did come true; upon the family of Roys Oatman.  He and his family eventually became followers of James Collin Brewster another of many who presented himself as the divinely appointed leader of the Latter Day Saints.    He taught that the true “gathering place” for the Mormons was at the confluence of the Gila and Colorado Rivers in present day Arizona. It was in search of their “Zion” that the Oatman family found themselves in February of 1851, along the banks of the Gila River.  Here is this remote, rugged place, Roys and Mary Ann Oatman and their children were brutally attached by local Indians.  All were killed but for two daughters who were taken prisoner, and a son who was left for dead.  While the younger of the two sisters died in captivity, the older sister lived to be rescued about 5 years later and was eventually reunited with her surviving brother.  The story of the “Oatman Massacre” was widely covered in the newspapers of the country and the event was forever immortalized by a Methodist minister, Royal Stratton, who’s book, “Captivity of the Oatman Girls”, first published in 1857, remained a best seller for decades.  The surviving daughter also helped with the celebrity by participating in a speaking circuit where she would share her harrowing experiences with large audiences.  The “Oatman Massacre” is a story of the west told and retold, most recently in the book, “The Oatman Massacre: A tale of Desert Captivity and Survival” written in 2006 by  Brian McGinty. 

No comments:

Post a Comment